Blog Post

Disguised Remuneration Schemes

Liam Bottomley • January 8, 2019

Also known as Contractor Loan Schemes and Employee Benefit Trusts

Following a well-publicised and ongoing campaign by HMRC to pursue taxpayers who have previously used or who are using schemes it believes have been designed to avoid tax, the countdown to the April 2019 Loan Charge is on.

Although the taxman has stated that they are aware that many participants in these schemes were unaware that they were avoiding tax or that they had been forced into participation in the schemes by an agency, potentially life-changing back charges for tax deemed to have been avoided must be paid by over 100,000 people in just three months’ time.

The April 2019 Loan Charge is targeting taxpayers who took part in certain loan arrangements, sometimes called “disguised remuneration” schemes or employee benefit trusts. In this article, Forths examines the history behind the Loan Charge and what you can do about it.

Employee benefit trusts – what are they?

Employment Benefit Trusts (EBTs) typically pay their members in tax-free loans which are never repaid by the loanee. Payments via EBTs are made instead of payment by salary.

Until the Finance (No 2) At of 2017, HMRC generally did not pursue those operating such schemes or benefiting from them because, to all intents and purposes, the practice was, for want of a better word, “legal”. The Act of Parliament changed that, giving the taxman the authority to charge tax on the members of such schemes right back until the tax year 1999/2000.

Most tax professionals argue that it is beyond dispute that many participants were motivated solely by their desire to avoid paying tax. However, accountants and other business professionals, arguing the case for their clients, insist that many were actively mislead by the providers of the schemes and the marketing agencies they used to promote the schemes.

What is the loan charge?

As a result of the Loan Charge, all outstanding loans will now be classified as earnings. Charges of up to 60% may be payable on those loans consisting of income tax and both the Employer and Employee versions of National Insurance.

HMRC will be able to send new tax demands on any disguised remuneration loans made since the 1999/2000 tax year including umbrella company loans.

The amount you pay will be based on the total of all unrepaid loans as if it was applied onto your personal tax account on the 5th April 2019. In most costs, the income tax and NIC payments will be collected through the PAYE system from the employer who arranged or agreed to participate in the disguised remuneration scheme. This employer must report and account for the loan liability via the RTI (Real Time Information) system with large sanctions available to HMRC if they fail to do so.

If the payment can not be collected from the Employer, HMRC will approach the individual themselves for payment.

What are your options?

If HMRC cannot collect the money it believes it is owed from the Employer who ran the scheme and they approach you, there are two choices:

pay the charge

attempt a voluntary settlement of any income tax owed with HMRC before the 5th April 2019.

HMRC have recently stated that people earning less than £50,000 a year can get a repayment plan of up to 5 years (assuming you’re no longer in a loan scheme) automatically. If you need longer than five years to make repayment in full, each case will be considered on its own merits and your individual circumstances.

Our team can liaise with HMRC on your behalf to ensure that the amount of unpaid tax you need to repay is accurately reflected and to agree the way in which repayment can be made.

Can I take action against the agency which sold me onto the scheme?

Yes, but it’s complicated and may be costly. You should seek legal advice prior to taking any action.

Voluntary Settlement

As mentioned above, HMRC will only be prepared to offer you any assistance on repayment for certain if you are no longer using these schemes. If you are still in one but want to get out, they will consider it.

Our experienced team have assisted many individuals in bringing their tax affairs up to date following their use of disguised remuneration schemes.

We can discuss your circumstances with you and explain the best way to take matters forward. We will liaise with HMRC on your behalf and guide you through the process from start to finish.

Contact Forths Tax

If you need assistance in bringing your tax affairs up to date, talk to our team on 0808 169 9090, email enquiries@forthstax.co.uk or fill out an Enquiry Form

By Liam Bottomley June 26, 2020
If you do not pay your tax there are a number of actions HMRC may take in order to recover unpaid tax debt. Depending on the circumstances this could take the form of either a tax investigation or HMRC debt enforcement action.
By Liam Bottomley June 26, 2020
“I’m late filling in my tax return” is a statement that we see time and time again in the enquiries that we see coming through from tax payers who have issues and are contacting us for assistance.
May 29, 2020
Let Property Campaign - Rental Tax Disclosure Case Study.We assist individuals in making disclosures of unpaid tax to HMRC and in investigations by HMRC. Call us on 0113 387 5670
May 27, 2020
Worldwide Disclosure Facility - Offshore Disclosure Case Study.We assist individuals in making disclosures of unpaid tax to HMRC and in investigations by HMRC. Call us on 0113 387 5670
May 26, 2020
Is Overseas Income Taxable?.We assist individuals in making disclosures of unpaid tax to HMRC and in investigations by HMRC. Call us on 0113 387 5670
May 22, 2020
How Far Back Can A Tax Investigation Go?.We assist individuals in making disclosures of unpaid tax to HMRC and in investigations by HMRC. Call us on 0113 387 5670
May 20, 2020
Are HMRC Manuals Always Right?.We assist individuals in making disclosures of unpaid tax to HMRC and in investigations by HMRC. Call us on 0113 387 5670
May 18, 2020
What is a Tax Investigation?.We assist individuals in making disclosures of unpaid tax to HMRC and in investigations by HMRC. Call us on 0113 387 5670
May 14, 2020
Furlough Fraud - Is There Such A Thing?.We assist individuals in making disclosures of unpaid tax to HMRC and in investigations by HMRC. Call us on 0113 387 5670
May 12, 2020
Are Tax Investigations On Hold?.We assist individuals in making disclosures of unpaid tax to HMRC and in investigations by HMRC. Call us on 0113 387 5670
Show More
Contact Us Here Today
Share by: